Buenaventura Press

"In January of 2010, I closed the doors at Buenaventura Press in Oakland, California."
-Alvin Buenaventura, via Blog Flume



The announcement of the closure of Buenaventura Press is perhaps the most important event in Art Comics since the announcement (and subsequent release of) Kramers Ergot 7.

This post will function as a continuously updating archive of the subsequent internet coverage of this event, as well as a forum for the possible effects this event will have on Art Comics and comics in general.

I personally am interested in the response, if any, Picturebox will provide, most likely via their flagship online publication Comics Comics. Picturebox and Buenaventura Press comprised a duopoly in the American publishing world of Art Comics. While Buenaventura Press was, at the time of its closure, still expanding within Art Comics, with forthcoming publications expected from new creators, Picturebox for several years has not expanded the stable of creators it publishes, and, according to its publisher Dan Nadel, does not plan to. The effect this has on young creators, and to some degree those creators previously affiliated with Buenaventura Press, is yet to be seen. As Jason Levian writes, "Their books have inspired new comic scenes all over the world." What will happen to these scenes now that the publisher who inspired them has ceased to exist? Levian continues, "I look forward to seeing the next generation rise from these ashes."

Who will publish this next generation? Pantheon Books, Fantagraphics Books, Drawn & Quarterly, and Top Shelf Productions, have all oriented themselves increasingly, within the past decade, around various aspects of art comics, in their content and production. High production quality and innovative printing techniques were trademark aspects of Buenaventura Press, and these aspects have increasingly been adopted by larger publishers. Experimental and non-normative content often associated with Art Comics have been regularly featured in Mome, D&Q Showcase, and recent anthologies by Top Shelf Productions. To what degree will larger publishers close the gap Buenaventura Press leaves behind? Will young creators find themselves accepted or adrift within this territory?

To what degree will the closure of Highwater Books, a "small but influential independent comic book publisher" and arguably the first American publisher of Art Comics, offer precedence?

[image removed]

What is the nature of the closure? Buenaventura writes, "the press experienced a devastating financial blow that made it impossible to continue." He adds, "I will release more details about this problem in the future." Sean T. Collins writes, "I talked to Alvin this afternoon and he told me it all comes down to a single problem that is legal in nature."

Twitter has become an archive of condolensces. Minty Lewis (@mintylewis) tweets, "i'm confused about why the buenaventura press announcement is being made 5 months after closing and also why it's still only half the story."

49 comments:

Sean T. Collins said...

You stay classy, Co-mix!

Jason Overby said...

Dan Nadel on Inkstuds

Jason Overby said...

Is there such a thing as "art comics" anymore? Is there anybody other than Picturebox that publishes only this type of work?

Sean T. Collins said...

Also today is 6/11

Blaise Larmee said...

thought it was july...

Frank Santoro said...

And you wonder why it pisses me off when everyone complains about books being priced high -
very few get how hard it is to be a publisher

Jason Overby said...

I lose $ when I self-publish my ultra lo-fi mini-comics. I can't imagine how difficult it would be to make any money publishing lushly printed, beautiful books.

Ian Harker said...

Time to go back to lo-fi. It's just an economic reality. Buenaventura and Picturebox put out beautiful books over the last 10 ears, but those were the fat years. Cheap credit and a surplus of disposable income are things of the past. This shit started with Paper Rodeo, time to take it back to basics. It's not the first time an economic reality shaped an aesthetic reality and it wont be the last. If the new generation of art comic artists ever need their wake up call this is it. Do things in a different way. Fort Thunder was just as much of an economic revolution as it was an aesthetic revolution. Buenaventura Press isn't going to be there for you anymore, Picturebox is playing it close to the chest, you've got to make it happen on your own.

Frank Santoro said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Blaise Larmee said...

damn that was the best comment ever to grace our blog

Frank Santoro said...

(ok, fine, here's the comment. I saved it. I erased it cuz I thought Ian's pro-scene rah team comment made me sound too wise-ass)

"Will young creators find themselves accepted or adrift within this territory?"

Adrift. Start swimming. Art Comics are going to be remembered like Undergrounds. It's already happening if you ask me.

Start working on that romantic comedy yaoi webcomic! At least you'll get reviewed on TCJ.com

Sean T. Collins said...

That IS a great comment.

tom Neely said...

self publish. small is beautiful. stay within your means. keep yr dayjob. make comics forever.

tom Neely said...

"Is there such a thing as "art comics" anymore?"

I'm kind of amazed that anyone would actually think that losing a publisher will somehow wipe out the existence of "art comics."

Anonymous said...

jeeze, I thought BP was going to last a little longer, it seemed that having their "indy" pamplets distributed by diamond was a big push in the profitable direction. What will happen to kramers, who will publish the next issue?

But really i don't consider BP to be that large of a publisher of so called "art comics." Most of their published books seem to be riding on some indy style (ex. Johnny Ryan, Ted May, Vanessa Davis, Lisa Hanawalt, Matt Furie, Kevin Huizenga.....) Ron Rege and Elvis Studio are the exception, and not nearly half of kramers is "art comics."

Anonymous said...

i knew something was wrong when they closed the webshop and when Alvin wasn't at MoCCA in person

Anonymous said...

it's kind of amazing that you guys are just finding out about this. rumors been circulating around for months.

Sam Gas Can said...

As I understand it, KE7 was intended to be the last issue. Also, we were aware, but rumors are rumors, facts are facts.

for Tom N.:
"Eventually, Mankind will evolve to appreciate underground comics."
-Gary Panter, 2002

Anonymous said...

i heard a rumor that the next kramers was going to be broken up into pamphlet sized issues, one artist per pamphlet, and that Kramers 8 would be the culmination of individual pamphlets released over a period of time.

can someone confirm this?

Anonymous said...

"Start working on that romantic comedy yaoi webcomic! At least you'll get reviewed on TCJ.com"

I would like to take this opportunity to contribute a statement about what we all already know: The Comics Journal has become a joke. What a waste of internet.

Frank Santoro said...

"i heard a rumor that the next kramers was going to be broken up into pamphlet sized issues, one artist per pamphlet, and that Kramers 8 would be the culmination of individual pamphlets released over a period of time.

can someone confirm this?"

It was to be a year of monthly magazine size issues - like 32 pages - 2 artists per issue - for one year. Sammy didn't say anything about a collection of the monthly issues. I was asked to contribute and I was doing a sci-fi story for issue two. Apparently, we were going to get paid. it still might happen. Kramers is Sammy's baby. Not Alvin's.

I never got paid for doing work for issue 7. Just a copy of the book.

Just saying.

Jason Overby said...

Tom - just meant "is there a place-art-comics-exist?" Too thorny to try to say "what is art comics?" Of course lots of folks are making good shit.

tom Neely said...

Yeah, that's all I was trying to say. This isn't the end of the world. It's the end of one good publisher. I'm sure everyone he published will find a new home and someone will fill in the gaps.

I also think people put too much faith in publishers as arbiters of taste.

That kramers 8 as a series idea is great. I really hope that happens. That's actually something I suggested before #7 came out, but I don't think anyone was listening to me.

It's really too bad to see Buenaventura close up. They will be missed.

Tim Hensley said...

I think Kramers 7 may have done Alvin in, but I think dealing with the printer more than the reception of the book was the problem.
It depresses me that it confirms the opinions of many still eager to abscribe nothing more than hubris to the whole endeavor, but there it is...
I've heard Kramers 8 may happen, not soon...
Despite book distribution and agents and all that, it's still not any easier for freaks than it's ever been. If there's no avenue to publish, you could just as easily be on the right path.

Uland said...

Yes, TCJ is dead in the water.
It's weird, but I think the fact that you guys all attend so many indie shows has maybe skewed your perception of "art comics" a bit. Maybe it's more in tune with the actual business of it all, but, from where I sit, B.P put out a handful of interesting books and that's as far as it goes. I didn't really regard BP as an institution with a really distinct line of books.
So, for me, it's more like I just hope those kinds of books will find their way into being.
It may be that, increasingly, we'll see a greater gulf between really high end books ( or prints) and the more middle ground works will go back to being self published.
I've been talking about it forever, but I'd still love to see a pulpy quarterly magazine that could present the better stuff from all quarters of the indie comics world. It'd be so much more compelling to see these competing visions duke it out in one magazine, with pages of letters in the back,etc.
Print it as cheaply as possible and sell it online. Forget big distributors..
But, yeah— I know it's always a little ridiculous to suggest to all of these independent creators with no money what ought to be done, but it's fun to play fantasy publisher.

Sam Gas Can said...

The indie convention circuit is definitely a strange and sometimes sickeningly personal world, but the "responsibilities" of a publisher remains a sticky wicket. Theoretically, there are none; whoever's in charge, it's their money, they can do as they like.

BUT, towards becoming an institution, where one's place is secured in the history books, then I suppose you have to start being picky. As far as being excellent designers, critics, and curators (distributing amazing minis and prints, including the Le Dernier Cri catalog), while also valiantly perpetuating the pamphlet format, BP absolutely were on the mark. I have heard arguments that they could have fostered more new talent (an exclusive club for comics elite, maybe at first?), and that their books were few and far between (24 total to my count?), but as Wikipedia notes, they “originally specialized in handcrafted fine press prints” so, assumedly, books were an afterthought to begin with and, in the big picture, they weren’t really around for that long, cut short in it’s infancy, barely given a chance to expand (their first book, Spaniel Rage, only came out in late 2005). Was their true distinction production value? Does it matter? The most important thing to remember is that, like Frank says, this shit ain’t easy and, like Tom says, nobody died. To his credit, Alvin accomplished a lot in the time that he did, and I’m sure his voice will remain prominent in the comics world and “blogosphere”.

Anonymous said...

Kramer's 7 was not the cause.

Uland said...

I'm not trying to devalue what they did, just trying to reorient the perspective to that of the non-insider.

Sam Gas Can said...

No, don't worry, I read into that, I'm ambivalent about the whole thing myself, hard to talk about this kind of thing without getting personal...

Blaise Larmee said...

some comments got quoted over here

Jason T. Miles said...

hey blaise,

please remove my photo from your post and in the future ask first (photos or drawings/comix).

for those who have seen my photo accompanying blaise's post and clicked on the link... know that we did not throw away copies of kramer's 7.

Desert Island said...

It seems like lots of scenes have started their own free (or cheap) newsprint publications in the wake of Kramers 7. This legacy alone is some small evidence of Buenaventura's influence.

In addition to the kinda-lame Wednesday Comics tabloid published by a little company called DC, there's Diamond Comics published by Floating World in Portland, Taffy Hips published by Gil and Zara in Providence or wherever they are, Secret Prison by Ian Harker in Philly, Kuti by Finnish crew, and Smoke Signal, my rag published in Brooklyn. There's probably more of them I don't even know about. There seems to me a yin+yang between Kramers 7 and these scrappy quarterlies, and the cultural impact will follow accordingly. (The voice of authority vs. the multitude, etc, etc)

Blaise Larmee said...

@jason ok

Jesse McManus said...

i'm continuously bemused and barfing when proper information about distribution systems, fickle lawsuits and uncouth rumors are shoved, nose-wards, in my direction. i'm lucky my friends are informers, but also sad.

a thick explosion within the niche!

a crack in the sidewalk, an undulating bowel. does a good life produce good process? many books were writ with blood hewn from strife. whatever life alvin is leading will surely be blessed by this catastrophe, if he chooses to accept such blessings.

what am i talking about? this blows ass. but at least he dodged the acronym bullet he would be suffering, had his press stayed active until current times. lately lots of dark, inky imprints being made, without alvin's help i'm afraid. too bad we can't battle furious fuel with Rives BFK as well as alvin commanded the ink tanks to smack his press.

luckily, we're all destined for dizziness, whether alvin takes us there or not. i'm ready to spin!

Austin English said...

jesse do you write that under the influence of the caterer?

Jesse McManus said...

yes, maybe, no, YES

now i'm going to go sleep in a pile of dried nerves, then dream of strangling hens, you bastard

everyone should read the caterer BTW

kicks everything's ass universe

Blaise Larmee said...

@jesse mcmanus i liked your blog post

Anonymous said...

Yah Jesse please write comments clearly. It's annoying.

dylan sparkplug said...

At this point on this blog "sense" doesn't really make sense.

Anonymous said...

nonsense is fun

Anonymous said...

laughter improves your blood pressure

so does owning cats and reading comics

Tim Hensley said...

The new tabloids seem more like a response to Paper Rodeo to me. Not much hubbub when that folded; I'd buy a book of it...

Anonymous said...

commentscomments.blogspot.com

dylan sparkplug said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
dylan sparkplug said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Desert Island said...

@ Tim =
Maybe Kramers Ergot #7 was a response to Paper Rodeo, and the newsprint phenomenon was a response to large format newspaper-sized books (including Kramers 7)? More people in the comics world have heard about Kramers and the similar Little Nemo books than Paper Rodeo anyway.

Tim Hensley said...

Well, @Desert Island, since you are among the newsprinters with Smoke Signal, I'll take your word for it! I've enjoyed the issues I've seen online.
I read that Sammy saw the Little Nemo book and thought, OK, let's do one of these with contemporary people in it.
I think the Sunday Press books led to more oversize reprints. I'm curious to see their new Krazy Kat one.
It'd be nice to think the Kramers book had more of an impact than on The McSweeney's $10 Comic Section (sounds like The Six Dollar Cheeseburger from Carl's Jr.).
Apologies; it's been really slow at work this week...

Desert Island said...

Yeah, you're right.

Want to do a page for Smoke Signal some time?

Tim Hensley said...

That's something I would like to do. I see you have changed your submission guidelines page; before I remember it saying you were hoping for newer people, so I wasn't sure whether I should try to submit (sort of like how I feel weird posting comments on this blog). I should email you anyway because I'm hoping you will carry a few of the black velvet posters I recently printed with Jordan Rae...